I Was a Teenage Frankenstein

Professor Frankenstein, now working in America, plans to successfully carry on his father's experiments by reanimating a teenage car accident victim. 1 HR 14 MINS 1957 American International Pictures

HORROR/SCIENCE FICTION

written by Gary Svehla

11/16/20268 min read

STORY

Amid dramatic orchestral music, with a focus on piano, Paul Dunlap’s music accompanies the credits. The first shot focuses on Professor Frankenstein (Whit Bissell) lecturing on organ transplantation. One colleague, Dr. Randolph (Marshall Bradford), challenges Frankenstein’s theories, but Frankenstein smiles and retorts that he will prove them someday.

Resting and reading at home, Professor Frankenstein watches as Dr. Karlton plays with electrical apparatus in the household laboratory. Karlton asks whether Frankenstein was offended by Professor Randolph’s criticism, and Frankenstein says he took it as a challenge. He plans to create a human being from assorted body parts in his private lab. He proudly plans to advance his ancestor’s work by successfully creating a monster. “I’ll point the way to perfection in the human race,” Frankenstein says. He’ll do the surgery while Karlton provides the electronics.

A loud crash sounds, and Frankenstein and Karlton run outside to see the tail end of a two-car collision, one car now ablaze. The two men carefully carry the body of a male inside and down to the lab. Karlton notes the corpse is horribly mutilated, the face terribly burned, and the skull crushed in. Frankenstein gathers house guests to say goodbye as he plans to return to the USA, but his nurse, Margaret (Phyllis Coates), sits alone, not ready to say farewell. Frankenstein proposes that Margaret become his full-time assistant, so they can grow closer and ultimately marry. But as the experiment advances with Karlton, Frankenstein spends less and less time with Margaret. She begins to feel neglected.

Frankenstein implores his teenage creature to speak. “Speak! I know you have a civil tongue in your head ... I sewed it back myself.” The young man's head is completely wrapped in gauze. Frankenstein has him say, “Good morning.” Later, Margaret enters his living area and threatens to investigate his experiment herself, but the professor becomes agitated, yelling at her and slapping her. Margaret begins to cry, and Frankenstein holds her and apologizes.

Margaret takes the always-locked laboratory and makes an impression. Returning home, she uses her duplicate key to enter the lab and immediately hears electrical apparatus crackling. She goes to the morgue and pulls out a slab where the heavily bandaged monster pops up, and she screams. Margaret rushes out of the lab and slams the door shut.

When Professor Frankenstein later returns home, he works to improve the reanimated teenager's speech by having him recite quoted lines. Then he works on the boy’s physique and strength. But Frankenstein always emphasizes that he is the master and the boy should listen only to him. Frankenstein’s creation exercises with barbells, showing off his shirtless torso. But he complains that he is always sad, kept secret, and hidden in the lab away from people. The professor says he will walk among people when he says, but the boy asks why not now? Frankenstein answers his question by cutting away his bandages and revealing his horribly mutilated face, and handing him a mirror; even with a disfigured face, he rants that he does not wish to be alone. But Frankenstein bellows that he will eventually fix his face to allow him to walk among people.

When the professor leaves the lab, the creation begins to wander around the house. He sits for a moment, rises, bangs on a piano, then keeps moving on. He eventually walks outside, startled by honking car horns. He peers into a neighbor’s window while the young blonde brushes her hair to jazzy music. After a moment, she sees the disfigured experiment staring at her and screams. He breaks the window and enters, grabbing the woman to silence her. But the hulking monster only murders her accidentally. As he slowly leaves the apartment building, a small group of people has gathered, and the boy pushes them aside. They scream and scatter as the monster flees outside.

The creation returns home to the lab, and when Frankenstein returns, he realizes the fiend escaped and killed a woman. He rants that he had to get out and see people. The boy is depressed that everyone who saw him ran away. He says he never meant to hurt anyone. Frankenstein yells that it may be too late to help him, but he says there’s a slim chance he can. But he must obey without question.

Soon two policemen ring Frankenstein’s bell and say they are investigating a fiend who is torturing this neighborhood. Frankenstein says he read the newspapers and knows the entire situation. The detectives ask their questions and say all six descriptions differ, but one common fact is that the fiend possesses a mutilated face. Then they exit. Looking for Margaret, he finds her with a jewelry salesman and promptly kicks him out, saying he doesn’t allow strangers in this house. Margaret is furious. She admits she went down to the lab and saw his monster, which shocks Frankenstein. She tells him she has a right to know more about his work to get to know him better, as his future wife. Frankenstein acts relieved and says it is better that she knows everything now. Frankenstein writes a blank check and tells her to buy the engagement and wedding ring immediately and wear the engagement ring at dinner tonight.

Going straight to the monster, Frankenstein tells him he'll work on improving his face tomorrow, but that the woman who works for him is inferring and threatening to go to the authorities. They both vow to stop her. That evening, Margaret admires her ring in front of her fiancée. Frankenstein wants Margaret to be an assistant to his creation for a few days, and she agrees. He goes downstairs to the lab with her to meet his creation again. Margaret administers a hypodermic to the boy and briefly leaves the lab. Frankenstein closes the lab door as the monster, in anger, pursues the woman, who is now screaming, and kills her. The professor returns and dumps her corpse into the crocodile moat beneath the laboratory.

Driving the monster to a lover’s lane, the boy picks a victim for a new face. The fiend attacks and kills the intended male victim. Later, the two detectives take a report from the teen’s mother describing the monster that killed her boyfriend. The mother describes her daughter fainting and awakening to find her boyfriend gone. In the very next scene, in Frankenstein’s lab, the monster smiles broadly, with Bob's face sewn onto his head. When Dr. Karlton returns, he asks about Margaret, and the professor says she left him cold; to survive this heartbreak, he must bury himself in his work.

Frankenstein is anxious to show his progress with his young creation, who sits and gazes at his new face in a hand mirror. Frankenstein has plans to move back to England by first disassembling his creation and reassembling him overseas, hiding the body parts in boxes of electrical apparatus. The professor gets the boy to lie on an operating table, telling him he is removing the stitches. But in reality, he will dissect him.

The boy is cooperative, but he begins to suspect something when they secure his hands and arms to the table. The boy breaks his shackles and fights to get off the table, fighting Frankenstein and Karlton. The boy chokes Frankenstein into unconsciousness and throws him into the moat below, the crocodile waiting. Karlton returns to the lab with two policemen, and they draw their weapons. In a special color sequence, the boy backs into electrical machines, which electrocute him as smoke and fire explode. The boy falls dead to the floor as Karlton says he will never forget his face after the accident. Then another shot of the monster appears as we zoom in, quickly cutting to the animal in the moat devouring Frankenstein as the cast of characters appear.

CRITIQUE

Nineteen fifty-seven was a great year for teenage horror, American International Pictures, and Herman Cohen. Cohen and Aben Kandel wrote the scripts for both I Was a Teenage Werewolf and I Was a Teenage Frankenstein, tremendous hits in the independent market.

AIP found a way to attract and bond with the newly emerging teen market, and they cashed in based on the movie’s demographics.

For two similar films like Teenage Werewolf and Teenage Frankenstein, both distributed by American International and written and produced by the same men, each film, beyond appealing to the teenage audience, could not have been more different. We recently reviewed I Was a Teenage Werewolf, so now we have to give a critical look at Teenage Frankenstein.

As noted, Teenage Werewolf starred future star Michael Landon, which gave it special appeal. Landon created teenage angst on steroids. The story was mostly told from his point of view, revealing all the demons that ruled his life. We followed him through high school, social clubhouses, parties, and rock-and-roll dances. We saw his character, Tony, meet his sweetheart's parents and witness the walls they built between them. We saw him clash with his father and his peers. Finally, we saw the psychologist who earned his trust and transformed him into a werewolf.

I Was a Teenage Frankenstein differs from the formula of the first film discussed. Here, the focus is on the adult Professor Frankenstein, and the teenager is his medical experiment, with a hulking body and a scrambled-omelet face. He is mostly seen as a human robot, blindly following his creator, totally (almost) subservient to his commands. While Tony is totally antisocial, Bob in Teenage Frankenstein wants to walk among people and be accepted for who he is.

Tony is the antisocial star of Teenage Werewolf, while Bob serves more as ugly window dressing, sitting alone for days in Frankenstein’s laboratory. Much of the picture shows him brooding, while the rest shows him longingly looking at his new, beautiful face in a hand mirror. For most of the movie, he sports a god-awful ugly face that allows no expression or movement. American International thought that the point of Frankenstein horror movies was creating the ugliest and most horrifying creature imaginable. Boris Karloff portrayed a reanimated corpse made from many diverse body parts. Yes, he was ugly, but he could convey emotion through his facial expressions, even crying. Gary Conway’s monster makeup was like a mask that covered his face, freezing the necessary emotions in place. He is nothing more than a mutilated muscleman.

Whit Bissell, who played the villainous psychiatrist in Teenage Werewolf, played another villain here: Professor Frankenstein. While Michael Landon was the troubled teen of Teenage Werewolf, here Bissell is the even more troubled adult in Teenage Frankenstein. He tries to maintain an adult relationship with Margaret while hiding in the laboratory; his experiments matter more than his relationship. Frankenstein cares more about making people obey him and doing things his way than about compromising, even when he should. He murders and reanimates as though God gave him personal permission.

Teenage Frankenstein has no teenage aspects of its society except for the lover’s lane local hangout where the good doctor can claim more victims. Teenagers are secondary to adult dinners, engagements, and unholy mancaves. Most horror movie fans prefer Teenage Werewolf because it features some realistic performances and tries to explain the life of troubled teens. Here, teens serve as support to a psychopathic adult who lives for the inflation of his own ego. Even when portrayed as monsters and murderers, teenagers are the sensitive ones who strive to walk among other people. Two teen-centric movies, each presenting a different view of society in 1957 America. Two exploitation films that appeal to teens in different ways: One dealing exclusively with teen angst, the other primarily dealing with a sociopathic adult.

THE TEENAGE FRANKENSTEIN MONSTER (GARY CONWAY) AND HIS FIRST ACCIDENTAL VICTIM (ANGELA AUSTIN).

THE TEENAGE MONSTER JUST WANTED TO GET OUT AND WALK AMONG REGULAR PEOPLE.

A BELGIAN POSTER FOR THE MOVIE

garysvehla509@gmail.com

DO YOU LIKE DARK CINEMA LIKE WE DO?

Submit an article or a critique of an article; Tell us how to improve the website!